Sildenafil, tadalafil or vardenafil: how the three tablets differ
Here you can compare the three tablets used for erectile dysfunction and ask a doctor to review a written questionnaire about which one fits you. All three work in the same way but differ in timing, in how long the effect lasts and in their typical side effects. This page explains how the doctor weighs those differences against your health and your other medicines, and when such tablets are not used at all.
One mechanism, three different timetables
Sildenafil, tadalafil and vardenafil belong to the same group, the PDE5 inhibitors. They relax the smooth muscle in the blood vessels of the penis, so that more blood can flow in when you are aroused. None of them produces an erection on its own: the product information for all three states that sexual stimulation is needed, and none of them increases desire.
Sildenafil is taken about one hour before sexual activity. Its product information notes that taking it with food can delay the start of the effect, so a heavy meal shortly before is a common reason why it seems to work less well.
Vardenafil is taken about 25 to 60 minutes before sexual activity, and a high-fat meal can delay its onset as well.
Tadalafil is taken at least 30 minutes before sexual activity, can be taken with or without food, and its product information describes an effect lasting up to 36 hours. That longer window suits men whose sex life is rarely planned. Tadalafil can also be used at a lower dose once a day by men who expect to use it at least twice a week; it is then taken at about the same time every day rather than before each occasion.
With any of the three, the limit is one dose a day: a second tablet adds side effects, not effect.
Side effects: largely shared, with a few differences
Headache is the most common side effect of all three. Flushing, indigestion, a blocked nose and dizziness are typical of the whole group. The product information for sildenafil lists visual disturbances among its common effects, for example colours looking different for a while. With tadalafil, back pain and aching muscles are among the most frequently reported effects.
Most of these effects are mild and fade as the medicine wears off. If one substance gave you troublesome side effects, or worked well and suited you, write that in the questionnaire: it is often the most useful single answer for the doctor, who may then consider another substance, a lower strength or simply continuing what works.
How the doctor decides which one, if any
Your preference counts, but the doctor chooses the substance and strength. To decide, the doctor reads how you describe the problem and how long it has lasted, how often you expect to use a tablet, whether you have taken one before and how it went, your other illnesses and every medicine you take, including those bought without a prescription.
Some answers change the choice. An alpha-blocker such as tamsulosin or doxazosin, combined with a medicine from this group, can lower blood pressure and cause dizziness on standing, so the doctor needs to know whether that treatment is stable and may start with a lower strength. Liver or kidney problems can also mean a lower strength, or a decision that the request belongs with a doctor who can examine you. If a recent blood pressure reading would help, you may be asked for one.
The doctor can ask further questions, request a document or decline; a refusal is a clinical decision about your safety, not a fault in the form.
When none of these tablets is used
Some situations are not about picking a gentler option. The product information lists them as reasons not to use any medicine in this group: nitrates in any form, such as glyceryl trinitrate or isosorbide mononitrate for angina, and recreational products known as poppers; riociguat; a heart attack or a stroke in the last six months; severe liver disease; blood pressure below 90/50 mmHg; an inherited disease of the retina such as retinitis pigmentosa; and a previous sudden loss of sight in one eye caused by poor blood flow to the optic nerve, known as NAION.
Unstable angina and severe heart failure are a separate matter. They mean that sexual activity itself may put too much strain on the heart, so treatment has to be discussed in person with your own doctor rather than through a questionnaire.
Urgent warning signs, and why your heart is part of the picture
An erection lasting more than four hours needs urgent medical help, because a prolonged erection can damage the tissue of the penis. A sudden loss or blurring of vision, or a sudden drop in hearing, means stopping the tablet and getting medical attention urgently. Chest pain during or after sex is an emergency: in Malta call 112, and tell the team which tablet you took and when, because it changes the treatment they can safely give.
Erection problems are not only a sexual matter. The changes in blood vessels that lie behind heart disease, and diabetes, often show up here first. Even when a tablet works well, it is worth having your blood pressure, blood sugar and cholesterol checked by your own doctor or at a health centre.
The prescription and the pharmacy
If the doctor issues a prescription, you receive it as a PDF by email. You print it and bring it on paper to a pharmacy in Malta together with photo identification. Your prescription is issued in the standard EU cross-border format set out in Directive 2012/52/EU. A pharmacy in Malta may dispense it; the decision rests with the pharmacist. It is not an ePrescription and does not appear in myHealth; it is outside POYC and the Government Formulary List, and you pay for the medicine at the pharmacy in full.
Your questionnaire is reviewed by Damian Wojno, a doctor registered with the Polish Medical Chamber, licence no. 3211301. The doctor is not registered with the Medical Council of Malta.
Is tadalafil stronger than sildenafil?
Not in the sense of being better. The three substances differ mainly in how long before sex they are taken and how long the effect lasts, not in a ranking of strength. Which one suits you depends on how you use it, how you tolerated earlier treatment and your health, and the doctor makes that choice from your answers.
Can I switch from one substance to another?
Yes, if the doctor considers it appropriate. Say in the questionnaire which substance and strength you took, how it worked and which side effects you had. Never take two different medicines from this group together, and never more than one dose a day.
Why did the tablet not seem to work the first time?
Common reasons are taking it too close to sex, taking sildenafil or vardenafil after a heavy meal, or expecting an effect without sexual stimulation. If it still does not help after several tries, tell a doctor rather than increasing the dose yourself.
Should my own doctor know that I use one of these medicines?
It is a good idea. Erection problems can be an early sign of heart disease or diabetes worth checking, and any doctor treating you for chest pain needs to know that you have taken a tablet from this group.
- European Medicines Agency: Viagra (sildenafil), EPAR
- European Medicines Agency: Cialis (tadalafil), EPAR
- European Medicines Agency: Levitra (vardenafil), EPAR
- European Association of Urology: Guidelines on Sexual and Reproductive Health
- Medicines Authority: prescription-only and non-prescription medicines, dispensing of EU prescriptions and validity